This week in America reveals a striking contrast between efforts to remember the past and moves to control the present. President Trump has directed the removal of slavery-related exhibits from national museums, sparking heated debates over how history should be remembered.
Meanwhile, in Greensboro, North Carolina, the nation bid farewell to civil rights leader Joseph McNeil, a man whose courage helped transform America. And in Memphis, Tennessee, residents are facing the presence of federal troops as the National Guard is deployed to “fight crime.” Together, these events highlight the complicated state of the nation.
The Trump administration’s directive to strip museums of slavery imagery has reignited controversy around how America reckons with its painful history. Among the exhibits affected is the haunting 1863 photograph “The Scourged Back,” which depicts the deep scars of Gordon, an escaped enslaved man. Displays at historic sites like Harpers Ferry and Philadelphia’s President’s House—where the realities of enslavement are central—are also under review.
Supporters of the policy claim that the nation should focus on progress rather than its darkest chapters, while historians and civil rights advocates argue that erasing these reminders undermines public understanding of slavery’s brutal legacy.
In Greensboro, however, remembrance took center stage as the community honored Joseph McNeil, one of the famed Greensboro Four whose 1960 sit-in helped spark a nationwide wave of civil rights protests. McNeil’s memorial service drew family, friends, and prominent figures, including Bishop William J. Barber II, who spoke about the enduring power of grassroots activism.
The sit-in at a Woolworth’s lunch counter, organized by McNeil and his peers, became a turning point in the civil rights movement, inspiring students across the South to confront segregation and eventually helping pave the way for the Civil Rights Act of 1964. McNeil’s passing is a reminder of how ordinary individuals can leave an extraordinary mark on history.
At the same time, President Trump’s decision to deploy the National Guard to Memphis has stirred concerns about federal overreach. The new “Memphis Safe Task Force,” announced on September 15, brings together Guard troops and agencies such as the FBI, ICE, and the DEA. Modeled on a recent intervention in Washington, D.C., the move comes despite Memphis facing challenges that local leaders believe should be handled without military-style oversight. Critics point out that similar interventions have occurred in places where crime rates were not at crisis levels, raising questions about the true intent behind the federal involvement.
These three stories—of erasure, remembrance, and enforcement—capture a nation caught between conflicting visions of its past and present. On one hand, the push to remove historical exhibits risks silencing voices that once defined America’s struggle for justice. On the other, the legacy of leaders like Joseph McNeil shows the transformative power of ordinary citizens standing up for equality. And in the streets of Memphis, federal troops now stand as a reminder of how power is exercised today. Together, they form a snapshot of the state of the United States—divided, complex, and still searching for balance.
About the Author
