Three moves the Cardinals must make this offseason

As the St. Louis Cardinals face their second consecutive playoff miss, the fanbase is eager for significant changes to rejuvenate the team.

The disappointing season highlighted key weaknesses, prompting discussions about what steps the organization must take before the 2025 campaign begins.

With a dedicated following ready to support the franchise at Busch Stadium, it’s crucial for the Cardinals to address their issues head-on this offseason.

After a rocky start to the season, the Cardinals showed signs of improvement, clawing their way back into postseason contention.

However, following the trade deadline, they suffered a dramatic downturn, leaving them scrambling to finish the season with a winning record.

To compete effectively in the National League Central next year, the Cardinals must undertake a few strategic maneuvers.

Letting Go of Hitting Coach Turner Ward

The offensive struggles have been glaring this season, with the Cardinals ranking among the lowest in the National League for runs scored and OPS.

Out of the eight players who appeared in over 100 games, only two managed to maintain a batting average above .270. Furthermore, the team has seen a disappointing lack of production from star players like Paul Goldschmidt and Nolan Arenado, both of whom are experiencing the worst seasons of their careers. While it’s important to recognize that not all blame falls on the hitting coach, a fresh approach is necessary to reinvigorate the offense. Cutting ties with Turner Ward would signal a commitment to change and an intent to restore the franchise’s historic success.

Trading Starting Pitcher Miles Mikolas

Currently, Miles Mikolas stands as one of the least effective starting pitchers in the league, making his $17.6 million salary seem unjustifiable. With a 9-11 record and a troubling 5.35 ERA, his performance has not provided the team with the stability it desperately needs. Despite his durability, having made over 30 starts for the last three seasons, the Cardinals require a more reliable arm in their rotation. This offseason presents an opportunity to trade Mikolas, even if it means absorbing some of his salary. By doing so, the team could open a spot for promising minor league pitcher Michael McGreevy, who is poised to step up in 2025.

Securing a Middle-of-the-Order Bat

With some financial flexibility this offseason, the Cardinals should prioritize acquiring a strong middle-of-the-order bat to complement their lineup. As Goldschmidt’s contract nears its end, it’s vital to add a power hitter who can deliver consistent run production. Among potential free agents, players like Anthony Santander of the Baltimore Orioles and Pete Alonso from the New York Mets would be excellent targets. Additionally, the Cardinals should revisit their interest in Brent Rooker of the Oakland Athletics. Rooker has showcased impressive numbers this season, boasting a .296 batting average along with 38 home runs and 110 RBIs. Acquiring him would require a strategic trade, but it could provide the offensive boost the Cardinals desperately need.

In summary, the St. Louis Cardinals are at a crossroads as they prepare for the offseason. By making these critical adjustments—parting ways with their hitting coach, trading an underperforming starting pitcher, and adding a powerful bat—the organization can lay the groundwork for a more competitive future. The fans deserve a team that strives for excellence, and these moves could be pivotal in reigniting the passion of the Cardinals’ loyal supporters.